In this funny, heartfelt, and surprisingly deep conversation, Russell Nohelty and Alex Dobrenko talk about what it really means to lead an audience today — especially when you feel like you have no idea what you're doing.
They explore the myth of the "ready leader," the reality of connecting with audiences in chaotic times, and why being human and honest beats being polished and perfect.
This episode is for anyone building a creative career, growing a community, or just trying to figure things out without burning out.
What You'll Learn:
Why having followers doesn’t mean having it all figured out — and why that’s perfectly okay
How Russell almost launched a cult (accidentally) with CultOfRussell.com
The real reason audiences reach out (hint: it’s about connection, not content)
How to manage your audience’s needs without losing yourself
Why leadership today is more about holding space than giving orders
The hidden emotional labor behind audience building — and how to handle it
How humor and self-awareness can keep you grounded as a public creator
Why messy comments and random questions are a feature, not a bug, of community life
How Claire Venus' advice reshaped Russell’s view of community management
Tactics for protecting your creative energy while still showing up consistently
Why engagement and empathy matter more than "being right"
How vulnerability creates stronger bonds than authority ever could
The importance of embracing awkward beginnings as part of the process
How to accept and even celebrate imperfection in yourself and your audience
Memorable Quotes:
"I have for years had a domain called cultofrussell.com. So I have actually been ready for a very long time — but it's hard to tell people what to do when I don't even know what to do."
"On some level, I feel like I should be providing solace. And you're just like — I can't do that right now. I'd like someone to provide solace for me."
"Sometimes I think people just want to connect with other people. That is what I have learned."
"Claire said something to me that blew my mind: 'I don't need them to be right. I just want them to feel heard.' And I think... that might be the key to everything."
"Trust isn't earned once. Trust is earned and re-earned every single time you post."
"People don't want to be given the right advice. They want to be told that the advice they already have is right."
"Without audacity, the books don't come out. Without empathy, the books suck."
"It's a weird time to be alive. It's a weird time to have followers. It's just a weird time to exist."
Key Lessons from the Episode:
1. You Don't Have to Be Ready to Lead
Russell and Alex dismantle the myth that leadership requires certainty. Instead, leadership today is about standing honestly in uncertainty and being willing to navigate it with others.
2. People Crave Connection, Not Just Resources
Audiences often reach out not because they need more information, but because they need human contact. Recognizing this can shift how creators interact with their communities — away from frustration, and toward genuine empathy.
3. Messy Conversations Are Healthy Communities
Inspired by Claire Venus' insights, Russell shares why letting comments, discussions, and posts evolve organically — even if they seem messy — creates a more authentic and welcoming space.
4. Protecting Your Energy is Part of Leading
Boundaries aren’t a betrayal of your audience; they're a necessity. Russell and Alex talk about how maintaining sustainable practices helps them continue showing up with authenticity.
Why You Should Listen:
This isn’t another "How to Build Your Audience in 5 Easy Steps" episode.
It’s a raw, funny, and refreshingly honest look at what creative leadership actually feels like in a chaotic world.
Russell and Alex don’t pretend to have all the answers — and that’s exactly why this conversation is so powerful.
If you're looking for real talk about showing up for your people (even when you're overwhelmed), creating sustainable relationships with your audience, and leading from a place of humanity rather than authority, this episode will hit home.
You’ll walk away with more courage, more clarity, and a lot more permission to be messy.
Share this post